Подробнее
Can you envision anything that will change your mind on this topic? OUR DISCUSSION -NO YES If one of your arguments is shown to be faulty will you stop using that argument (with everyone)? -NO—* This is not a discussion. I will not talk to you about this topic. YES Are you prepared to abide by basic principles of reason m discussing this topic. YES JL This is a discussion. I will talk to you about this topic provided the following rules are obyed Thank you for requesting to have a discussion with me about this topic. Discussions are a dialog between people in which the participants are willing to alter their position if it makes sense to do so. Sometimes, people confuse "discussion" with “sermon" or lecture." These non discussions are a waste of time since all parties are intractable in their existing views. So that our time is not wasted please use this guide to determine whether we can actually have a discussion about — this topic. Examples: • The position that is more reasonable and has more supporting evidence should be accepted as irue. • The person assorting a position bears the onus of demonstrating its truth. 1. Do no! introduce new arguments while another argument has yet to be resolved. 2. Do not move on to another argument if it is shown that a fact you have relied upon is inaccurate. 3. Provide evidence for your position or arguments. 4. Do not argue that you do not ‘need’ evidence. 1 Did you breach any of these rules in the discussion? You cheated —YES ► The discussion is terminated. NO JL CONGRATULATIONS This is how rational human beings exchange ideas. You are deemed to have conceded all opposing arguments up to this point. You forfeit any right to complain about the discussion.
Рациональная дискуссия,перевод в комментах,песочница
Еще на тему
0.0
